PCAOB Wallops KPMG Netherlands With Record $25M Fine For Exam Cheating

A fine of $25 million to the Netherlands arm of Big Four firm KPMG for systemic exam cheating over a five-year period is the largest financial penalty doled out thus far by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), the U.S. audit regulator said on April 10.

The PCAOB found that widespread improper answer sharing occurred in the firm’s internal training program and that KPMG Netherlands lied to the PCAOB about its knowledge of the rampant cheating.

The firm’s former head of assurance, Marc Hogeboom, received a permanent bar and a $150,000 fine from the PCAOB.

“The PCAOB will not tolerate cheating nor any other unethical behavior, period,” PCAOB Chair Erica Williams said in a statement on Wednesday. “Impaired ethics threaten the investor confidence our system relies on, and the PCAOB will take action to hold firms accountable when they fail to enforce a culture of honesty and integrity.”

From 2017 to 2022, hundreds of professionals at KPMG Netherlands engaged in improper answer sharing—either by providing access to test questions or answers, or by receiving such access without reporting it—in connection with tests for mandatory firm training courses, according to the PCAOB. These courses related to a variety of topics, including U.S. auditing standards, professional ethics, and independence.

The improper answer sharing reached as far as partners and senior firm leaders, including Hogeboom.

According to the PCAOB, an investigation uncovered that the firm knew as early as June 2020 that answer sharing had occurred at a KPMG service delivery center serving the firm’s Dutch and U.K. arms, but KPMG took very few steps to investigate the exam cheating among its personnel until a whistleblower stepped forward in July 2022.

During the PCAOB’s investigation, KPMG Netherlands submitted—and failed to correct—multiple inaccurate representations to the audit regulator. The firm claimed to have no knowledge of the exam cheating until it received the July 2022 whistleblower report. These submissions, reviewed by the firm’s management board (of which Hogeboom was a member) and supervisory board, were false, the PCAOB said, because members of those two boards were found to have participated in the exam cheating before July 2022. 

As part of its settlement with the PCAOB, KPMG Netherlands also agreed to review and improve its quality control policies and procedures to provide reasonable assurance that its personnel no longer cheat during internal training, and to report its compliance to the PCAOB.

In a statement, KPMG Netherlands CEO Stephanie Hottenhuis said, “The conclusions are damning, and the penalty is a reflection of that. I deeply regret that this misconduct happened in our firm. Our clients and stakeholders deserve our apologies. They count on our quality and integrity as this is our role in society, with trust as our license to operate.”

Robert Rice, director of the PCAOB’s Division of Enforcement and Investigations, said the penalties issued today to KPMG Netherlands “send a signal to firms and their leadership that they have a responsibility to set an appropriate tone at the top, particularly with regard to issues of integrity and personnel management.”

Since 2021, the PCAOB has sanctioned nine registered firms for quality control deficiencies related to the inappropriate sharing of answers on internal training exams, including Big Four firm Deloitte’s arms in Indonesia and the Philippines, which were each fined $1 million on Wednesday for exam cheating.